I've seen anthracite and vert gazon gh in person, both were great. I've never seen gh with vert d'eau. I think I prefer vert d'eau, but not having seen it in person with giant makes it hard to say. The anthracite also grabbed me when I saw it at Saks.... I just want to make the right choice, so I can keep the one I pick.Do you like the VG at all? how did you feel about Vert D'eau?
OMG that sandstone is a gorgeous one. I say keep it. It goes with everything. But if you really don't love it, I think VG is TDF with GH.