Yes, we've discussed this...on another thread, and I agree that the new white is stark. That said, I saw it on Bluefly and took a chance and bought it anyway, since it was discounted 20%. I have the '06 ivory in three bags, the medium paddy, the large US Shopper from fall '06 (which is still on neimanmarcus.com btw), and the large zippy bowler.
I do like the ivory from '06 better than the new white. But the new white sort of grows on you.
It's a very summery bag
At first, when I saw it at Neiman's I thought...Ugh, too white. But now I really like it. I have to say that the real deciding factor in keeping it, was that the leather is really pretty on this particular one, and the one I saw previously at Neiman's had a stiffer leather!
I have no idea why the leather on the Bluefly one was soft and squishy (yes, it's real, I checked it out at Neiman's just to be sure and compared it as well to my other paddys...it all checks out
) Perhaps it depends on the factory. Chloe is not real consistent about this sometimes. In the early years, they were, but it seems since '06 some of the quality control changes from bag to bag! So even though I like some of the other whites more than the stark white, the bright white is lovely when the leather is wonderful.
I have the creme from neimanmarcus and the leather is great on that bag. I think I am more picky about the leather than the color! I seem to like the color if the leather is excellent. (!) Part of the Chloe addiction!