If I haven't "used it", maybe just a test - then it goes back. Sephora has a pretty good return policy. (They allow you to return things that have been tested if you don't like them, they just don't restock them when you let them know that... Just want to make sure ppl know that I'm not returning used stuff as new!!)
If I have used it a few times and just don't like it, I hand it down to my nieces or just throw it away...
I'm trying to stick with things that I really think I would like lately - because the second option was getting expense there for a while. :shame: