Only you can say if the cost of the name on the box is worth it to you. I've ordered multiple times from Blue Nile and have never been disappointed. Their products are generally great quality and they are fantastic about returns in the event you are dissatisfied. I do, however, see a difference between the two pendants. That doesn't necessarily make one better than the other, but they aren't identical. If you are picturing the Tiffany design, the Blue Nile piece won't be identical, and if you will find that disappointing then the cost is worth it.