I love the tattersall but I would only get that if you have other bags that you love and you wont want to wear that every day. Im so scared of the white clothes & staining! The legacy print is also soo delicate that I wouldnt get it unless you were only looking to have something to use once in awhile for special occassions. If youre looking for more of an every day bag I would def go for the Carly. The color is gorgeous and it will last much longer. Id hate for you to get the tattersall or legacy print, spill a tiny bit of soda or something on it, and have to throw it out!