I've seen some of you post about the Katy and some of the other new bags with shiny leather. Do you love these as much as the more traditional leather (e.g. Elisha or Paige)? I feel the shiny leather is probably going to be durable and can take rain, etc. but it doesn't feel or smell as nice. Reason I'm asking is that I'm trying to choose between a Botkier Bianca in chocolate smooth leather or rust shiny leather. The rust visually packs more punch but you lose the smell and touch. What say you ladies who have shiny bags? Thanks.