Thanks for all the replies. I cant see both the bags at the same time as one is in my local store and the other is an international order. I have enough of both casual or dressy bags so i really dont need either. The met black reissue is beautiful but the tarnished chain against the black met leather doesnt stand out. There is no contrast. I'll prob go for the distressed caviar and return it if it doesnt turn out to be what I want.