Ok, since my first choice of handing your entire collection (amazing!) over to me was not an option , I would go with the pink if you love it . . . I think there will always be a great black bag to add to your collection season to season, but the pink is unique. Also, I like the added appeal of the leather shoulder strap, I would love that on a bag just because if you do have the odd day when it is loaded up it does make a diff. in how your shoulder feels at day's end! Enjoy whichever one you choose, both would be great.