The rule of bag buying:
It's not whether they're over, it's whether you're over them.
Chloe is a totally unknown brand in my city (Baton Rouge, LA), so the Paddy is neither in nor out. I guess if you live somewhere more fashion-forward, this is more of an issue. If you still love it, rock it!
I agree with Kore. If you love it, it's always in.