Need help - Givenchy or Celine??

[bumble1]

I recently bought a distressed Givenchy Pandora in the sand color (light peachy beige with slightly darker veins throughout) and a Celine zipper Cabas in black. I really like both and they are very different, but I only want to keep one. I already have a lot of black bags, making me think I should pick the beige Pandora, but I already have a Pandora in black and I fear this color may be too summery.

Which bag do you prefer for me? Is the Cabas too long? Or... feel free to say neither!

Thanks so much!

 

[margaritas]

I was gonna say, get rid of the Pandora since you already have one in black, but the Cabas looks a little too big on you!

 

[bumble1]

I was gonna say, get rid of the Pandora since you already have one in black, but the Cabas looks a little too big on you!

Thanks for the objective feedback - my first reaction to the Cabas was that it was a little too large (it feels a little smaller once all the tissue paper I have in it now is removed). But then I convinced myself it wasn't too big because it's a lovely bag. Such decisions! Thanks though; this helps a great deal.

 

[margaritas]

I love the Cabas too! I have tried on one at my local Celine store but it's much smaller than the one you have.

 

[DisCo]

The Pandora looks amazing on you and the colour is just beautiful. The cabas looks too big on you plus it doesn't seem as versatile.

 

[chikapinku]

The Pandora looks stunning on you. The Cabas is way too big.

 

[SkyBlueDay]

Keep your Pandora: it can be worn in a few different ways, and I think it looks in lovely proportion on you.

 

[curvednglam]

I like the pandora , but you already have it in black. I dont like the cabas on you at all- it seems way too big. If you love the pandora- keep both colors

 

[HandbagAngel]

Both are pretty. But I think the Celine is too big on you. Givenchy would be a great summer bag, and it is lovely. I'd keep Givenchy.

 

[linhhhuynh]

i prefer the Pandora!!

 

[Tokimeki]

Ugh, conundrum! The Cabas is a tad big, but you can pull it off - I refuse to think any bag is too big, just depends on how you wear it! If I hadn't have known you had a Pandora in black, though, I would definitely say keep this one. The color is superb.

I think you'll be happy either way! But if I really have to pick one... I say the Cabas.

 

[allimac]

I think you should keep the Givenchy - the Celine is too big on you!

I recently bought a distressed Givenchy Pandora in the sand color (light peachy beige with slightly darker veins throughout) and a Celine zipper Cabas in black. I really like both and they are very different, but I only want to keep one. I already have a lot of black bags, making me think I should pick the beige Pandora, but I already have a Pandora in black and I fear this color may be too summery.

Which bag do you prefer for me? Is the Cabas too long? Or... feel free to say neither!

Thanks so much!

 

[allimac]

You should keep the Givenchy I think - the Celin bag looks to big on you

 

[ilovepapayamilk]

I have a black pandora, and plane to got my second one. You know what I'm gonna say...Keep Pandora. I love Celine, but it's just too big on you. Just a little bit smaller, it will be perfect.

 

[indiaink]

Pandora, hands-down. Celine is too big for you - physically overwhelms you.