Madeline-sig or leather?

[alatrop]

The way it looks in this picture (the girl in the blue skirt) makes me want a leather one so bad! It looks broken in and gorgeous!!!!

http://www.coach.com/assets/images/downloads/wallpapers/coachMADELINE_1024x768.jpg

 

[pat222]

I personally don't think that any Coach signature bags look 'cheap'. I happen to like the signature and think it would be a fun spring bag, but it is a bit more casual. Now if the pond rumor turns out to be true.....

 

[MsAmie]

I have large white/khaki signature Madeline and I love her--the white is perfect for spring/summer. She has a very special place in my heart.

 

[LAltiero85]

Get the leather. The signature looks tacky and cheap.

On behalf of all those who own signature bags.....thanks! FYI, they're NOT cheap at all. There are better ways to state an opinion.

 

[ktheartscoach]

Thanks for saying that, LA!

Am I allowed to say that being tactful and nice is neither tacky nor cheap?

And either the sig or the leather would be great...if I weren't on a ban I would be all over that bag.

 

[Taralindsey]

Get the leather. The signature looks tacky and cheap.

Well.. I like leather better than signature but it does not look cheap or tacky!

:s

 

[tlloveshim]

Here's 11553, the medium in magenta:

Also, the patent madeline is #11789 $498 but the catalog I have doesn't give the color choices.

 

[ktheartscoach]

That magenta is TDF!!! I can't wait for someone to buy it!!! I'm on a ban, but that doesn't mean I can't live vicariously through others!!!

 

[runner22]

Thanks ladies!

 

[LAltiero85]

Thanks for saying that, LA!

Am I allowed to say that being tactful and nice is neither tacky nor cheap?

And either the sig or the leather would be great...if I weren't on a ban I would be all over that bag.

I couldn't have said it better myself!

 

[LAltiero85]

Thanks ladies!

have you decided what you want?

 

[Crazy for Bags]

I like the leather, I also, am not much of a siggy girl.

 

[runner22]

have you decided what you want?

I really like the geranium leather one, and the khaki/mahogany sig one. ahhhh!

 

[ashdir103104]

I saw both at the store today. I wasn't a fan of the geranium because it was too orangey for me. I liked the khaki/mahogany if I had to pick one or ther other.

 

[Kenia]

tacky AND cheap

Well I think it looks sophisticated and expensive.