LV Neverfull PM or Dooney Dr. Satchel

  1. I'm debating on which one to buy--the LV Neverfull PM or Dooney Dr. Satchel in Marine. I've been looking for a handheld navy bag so when I saw the Dooney one, I was :drool:. Then I saw the Neverfull, and I was :drool:. Both are somewhat "similar" in price--$425 and $575. I prefer handheld bags and I think both can be carried this way. I just can't decide which one to get. What is your vote? Thanks for your help!

    [​IMG][​IMG]
     
  2. 'll be honest. Dooney goes on sale, and LV doesn't. So if you are looking for a bag that will hold it's resale value, then buy the LV. You'll probably be able to buy the Dooney at outlets within the next year or so for about 30% off, if not more.

    Regarding appearance, the Dooney looks more professional and the neverfull more casual. Maybe you should try a speedy?
     
  3. I like the Neverfull PM.
     
  4. I like the Neverfull. Get the Dooney on sale.
     
  5. i prefer the Neverfull too although I love that shade of blue!
     
  6. the neverfull is so much better! I recently got a GM and totally love it!
     
  7. Neverfull Neverfull!
    I've been looking into getting one too!
    (then again I have been looking into getting a lot of things)
     
  8. This may be a dumb question, but why is the neverfull so cheap? For such a decent sized bag it's really an excellent price? You guys know something about it that I don't?

    It looks like great style and I definitely think you should go for it!!! The Dooney is nice but I agree with pp's, you'll be able to eventually get it for a lot cheaper if you still want it in the long run.
     
  9. Hardly any hardware, very simple shape and easy to make- It also has very few leather parts.
     
  10. Maybe LV is seeing how inflated all bag prices are and is competing with a few lower-priced bags (and fairly priced!).
     
  11. my vote goes to LV without a doubt
     
  12. I LOVE the Neverfull, so that one gets my vote. I am SO not a Dooney fan.
     
  13. You have to go with the Neverfull! I'm debating getting one myself....I just can't decide what size.....:confused1:
     
  14. The only thing about the LV is that the handles look very thin. I really don't see it as much of a hand-held bag because of that. Also, it looks like it just has a center top closure which may be a concern if you are worried about keeping things inside. I think the Dooney is more interesting style-wise and I like the color. It really depends on what type of look you are going for. Dooney does go on sale, but I would consider which bag I want rather than that. Personally, I would go with the Dooney... but I don't carry logo bags so take that with a grain of salt!!
     
  15. I agree with everyone else. Get the Neverfull now. You can always get the Dooney on sale later.