You'll need to possess (or be able to view in person) one of these leather Bleeker Shoppers with the Coach-engraved flap, AND have the last catalogue that featured this bag to figure out the answer. The 2007 fall/winter catalogue features a leather Bleeker in Whiskey, without the engraving on the flap. That's one of five differences between the Bleeker you may have, and the one in the catalogue picture. I just told you what the most obvious difference is (which is also the least significant). Can you find the remaining four? Those differences are not trivial, considering the prices were the same! I'll be back later to see how it's going . . .