Tough one because I have both. I have a black MC Petite Noe which I love (except for that vachetta bottom) and I use it more than my White MC trouville. I bought the white trouville 1st and I think it is my prettiest bag that I have. I am trying to use it more often but the Noe is more convienient when I need my hands free for my kids. I don't think I have been much help. Do you want a handheld or shoulder?