Ok, hands DOWN the red tie-dye Itzels. Those pants are HAWT, HOT, HOT! The color is amazing and it truly is flattering on everyone. I have both the Ziane and red tie dye itzels. I just purchased my red itzels from NAP this week. I can tell you, by far, these pants make anyone look good. They are so HOT. The fabric is thicker then the Reo's or Ipa's and has elastic/stretch similar to the Reo's and Ipa. The denim is the thickness of the Zilah/Ziane. It makes the leg look slimmer because of the thicker/more supportive fabric. The color makes them pop! They are very flattering. If you ever tried the Renells, they feel like them (where they hold everything in ). They do seem to run a touch smaller then the Reo's or Ipa's. But the denim is stretchy so it feels fine imho. If you prefer a more relaxed look then I would size up. My vote is the red itzels, you won't regret it! I think with your height you will make these pants look amazing. The only downside is that you might be able to find a similar pants for cheaper because everyone is doing tie dye this summer. But the pattern of the tie dye makes the leg look long!