I voted for the azur speedy. I've owned every bag on your list and sold them all except my azur speedy 30. Here's my opinions, for whatever their worth......the trouville looks like a little suitcase, it's cuter in the MC than mono though because of the studs. The manhattan made me panic all the time....didn't want to scratch the hardware. The reade is open and too small. I've owned a lot of LV in my life...buy, sell, buy, sell. FINALLY, I have found the bag I love and it's the speedy 30. I have it in mono, azur, and patchwork.