I have the Lg Khaki/Saddle Carly and think she's just beautiful. Honestly. I got her the first weekend of PCE and she still has her tags. I haven't even thought to grab her. To me, that says this is a bag that I love looking at, but the style may not be for me. At least maybe not the color. I like the larger size, but I'm thinking that there's a reason that I lack any signature pieces in khaki, and that I carry signature pieces less and less. I used to love it, but in my current hometown, it feels and looks showy. I admit it. I think I like the chocolate signature Carly, but then again I just bought a whiskey Ali. That should last me with a brown bag. Also, how well has the fabric held up over the winter for everyone that has them? Any suggestions on what to do? I'm seeing several options: 1. Keep the Carly, pray I feel like using her. 2. Totally return with no exchange (and make my credit cards a bit happier) 3. Exchange the Carly for the chocolate signature 4. Exchange the Carly for something else. I've been thinking about this, and really the only things I may want are: Patent Ergos (but I have the red hobo and mahogany tote. I don't need another bag, particularly since it's the mahogany hobo I'm lusting over), white Ali (but too impractical... and I do. not. need. 5 Alis. period.), Lg Ergo Totes (but they're at the outlets). I'm stumped.