OK, here is the story. Tuesday night I purchased several things (2 bags, umbrella, 2 scarves) using my PCE discount. The SA gave it back to me and told me I could use it again. I received everything Thursday. I decided the Turquoise Ergo wasn't really for me and the umbrella's stripes weren't lined up, so I went in to Coach today to exchange them. I brought the umbrella and ergo in WITH the receipt/packaging slip from Jax and gave it to the SA at the register. I reordered the umbrella (hoping for a match this time) and a cross body, the NEW Legacy stripe tote and Concentric striped scarf. They didn't say anything about new items not counting for PCE and just rang it all up, I gave them my PCE card and left happily to await my new items coming with my PCE discount. BUT, I started thinking that it should have been more money. So, I got out my calculator and added everything up and realized what had happened. They didn't discount my returns with the 25% off. So, in essence, I received the 25% off of the new items, but got full credit for the old items, even thought they were purchased with the PCE 25% discount. She had the receipt/packing slip in her hand. The same 2 people who helped me before helped me again, althought they asked someone to ring it up. She is the one I gave the packing slip/receipt to. The manager was there, also, and even went in the back to get me a new catalog! They had all the info! What do I do? I did nothing wrong here, but now I feel guilty. Do I call them up and point out their mistake and bring them $114 for there mistake? Do I say nothing, since obviously they didn't realize it? I am going to feel like an idiot walking back in there, giving them money for nothing and I am going to feel guilty if I do nothing. What do I do?