I love the Mahina ... so definitely keep that! I have not seen #3 irl so I'm not sure about that one. IMO #2 is okay. But based on your pics, my choice would be #1 and #3.
I love the Mahina, so I would def keep it. I would keep number 3 also, I prefer it to the Rubis (I don't like Rubis line so much..)
So my vote goes towards 1 & 3!
thanks everyone, such great feedback. while I really like #2, the Mono Rubis, I think it is too big and boxy on me and the straps are too long and it hits me in the wrong place, it would work great as an occassional/travel tote, but not for everyday! And while I can jusitfy spending that much on an everyday bag like #1 and #3, I cannot spend that much on a bag that will sit in my closet...I would never take it to disneyland while on vacation for the summer! I jsut picked up an quite Orla Kiely coated canvas tote at anthropology, I think that will suffice as my summer tote and can be worn at the beach or disneyland!
thanks everyone so much, you are all so terrific!