on line it says it is 2" wide and in the catalog it says 4" wide. I really want it to be 4" wide. I just received my large carly, and it doesn't fit nicely under my arm. I love my new Leigh in raisin, but it works in the crook of my. I want a shoulder bag that is comfortable. If the hobo is 2" I might just have to get the Thompson top handle and live with 2 bags in the crook of my arm. I need to know so I can send Carly back and get the other one before PCE ends! TIA!!!!!!