Help!!! Keep it or Change it????

[beljwl]

In this tread I asked which ring everyone liked better. http://forum.purseblog.com/the-jewelry-box/which-ring-do-you-like-better-247404.html My favorite one won the the poll.

Now I need help again.

I went to Vegas today and picked up the ring (and a few other goodies and even more to come)

Here is what the ring looks like right now. Should I keep it the way it is or change it to the winner of my other thread? Sorry for the huge photo.

Here is what I was thinking of changing it to

 

[fabgrabs]

Awww, beljwl, the setting it's in is gorgeous, but the poll winner setting would, I think, showcase the stone "mo betta", so that was my vote.

 

[JoeyJo21]

That is such a beautiful stone, and IMO it would look even better in the new setting. I vote to change it ^_^

 

[L etoile]

I would love to see that stone with a thinner band

 

[Leelee]

I still love the setting that was voted number 1 the best.

 

[Kellybag]

Do you feel the need to change it? If yes, why?

I do love the setting you are thinking about a great deal, but one thing to note...your setting is unique and it looks nice on you. I could honestly go either way.

 

[couturequeen]

I would change it - I prefer the other setting.

 

[Kitsunegrl]

I would change it. I think the new setting would give it a more modern, updated flair.
I just had my 40+ year opal ring reset into a new setting and it looks so great. My mom was trying to snag it back!

 

[article3]

Change it, fo sho! The current setting, IMHO, makes the diamond look smaller, and a setting like the one above w/the baguettes will really show off the diamond more!

 

[Crystalina]

I agree, a daintier, thinner band is much more becoming, much more elegant. I guess it just depends on your personal preference, but I don't like big, chunky jewelry, so I'd change it!

 

[elizat]

I would change it, unless you want the current setting for sentimental reasons. I think the new setting would make the stone pop even more and update it.

 

[ame]

I LOVE the bag side-stones...absolutely change it.

 

[glitter8188]

i might be a lone thinker here, but i think the current setting is more interesting, the other looks ordinary

so i voted keep it, it's a nice setting. but that's just what I think

 

[kh9079]

I vote for this one!