we are the same size, I am 5'3" and sz 6/8. i prefer the GST, it just fits really well under your arm, looks great dressy or casual. I sold my cerf tote, it was too small to fit comfortably on the shoulder. for that expense, i want to carry it on my arm or shoulder or in my hand! I'd strongly recommend the GST, plus they sure seem to be holding their value from an investment standpoint!