Also, gourmand scents are big right now, so there's a lot of vanilla, caramel, cookie, cake, creme brulee type of scents that have a sweet vanilla smell. A lot of men really like those!
If you can track down the discontinued Tutti Dolci line from Bath and Body Works, I think you'd really like those scents, if that's what you're going for. I have the Creme Brulee and Chocolate Fondue body cremes and they're soooo yummy. You just want to eat them!! I think they sell them occasionally at TJ Maxx.
^ OMG! Yesssssssss
They were the best! I still have the Creme Brulee Shower cream and the Sugar Wafer body souffle. I try not to use them too much, because I'm going to be so sad when they run out!
I get a lot of compliments on Britney Spears Curious. If you ignore the fact that it has her name on it, it's a good scent. It's a bit strong when you first spray it but it dries down to a nice woodsy note. Very sophisticated and it has good staying power.