Best eyeliners that won't smudge on oily lids

[sadhunni]

revlon colorstay

 

[luvmy3girls]

mac fluidline!! they have so many pretty colors too, so you can expand from the basic black!

I these...I use it as eye shadow..and it lasts all day.

 

[tweetie]

I love MAC fluidline as well... stays on for me, even with swimming, and it's not too expensive.

 

[songofthesea]

bobbi brown gel eyeliner...they don't budge until you take them off at night...

 

[jewald]

bed head eyeliner really stays on strong too

 

[ceramic]

Revlon & Almay have long lasting eye pencils, their watrerproof eyeliners are superb

 

[yeppun_1]

I LOVE Lancome's Artliners.

I second Artliner! I use the color Noir

 

[rin]

bed head eyeliner really stays on strong too

Ooh, I didn't know they made makeup too. Where do you get them?

 

[StaceyLS83]

MAC fluidline is the absolute best! Blacktrack is a great color.

 

[miss-lilly]

I also agree with everyone that MAC fluidlines are great so Blacktrack would be a great choice! They last all day without smudging
I also love Bobbi Brown's gel eyeliners and Stila's Smudge Pots

 

[jaycee]

I've tried MAC, Chanel, Stila & Make Up Forever pencil eyeliners, and I definitely say Make Up Forever is the best! Does not smudge all day! : )

Though I must say they are ALWAYS out of stock - very annoying.

 

[ShimmaPuff]

I have very oily skin, and I use Palladio pencils. Good colors, soft enough not to pull the skin, but substantial enough to stay put despite the inhospitable eyelid environment.

Get them at Sally's, some drugstores have them, they are about $3 a pop.

 

[ally24k]

i looove laura mercier's cake liner (eyeliner in a eye shadow pan). it never smudges on me and stays on well all day.

 

[rin]

I've recently started using L'oreal's waterproof eyeliner, because of the whole Lancome = L'oreal thing, and I must say, it works WONDERS. It stays on ALL day, and is easy to take off too!

 

[boudoir]

I use a Sisley pencil. It has just a wee bit of shimmer and it stays well.