Best eyeliner?

[toiletduck]

i used to use the MAC pencil liner but that smudged on me so i switched to NARS Black Moon. It's soft enough so that if you want to do a smokey eye look, it smudges well.

if you want it to stay put (i go clubbing every day friday and it STAYS), i apply black eyeshadow over the liner to set it. this works on my bottom lids too.

 

[lil miss cheeky]

mac fluidline defo

 

[piperlu]

I have been using Dior and Mac eyeliner pencils.

I recently tried and love Sue Devitt eye intensifier pencils. They're the fatter pencils but they help you achieve a smokey look if that's what you want or you can smudge it out and wear it as shadow. Pretty good stuff. Beautiful colors.

 

[xikry5talix]

Le crayon khol in black ebony by Lancome. I've used tons of other but always go back to this one!

 

[graceful]

bobbi brown gel eyeliners are the best. So easy to apply. And it does not pull on your eye area, whereas for me, the pencil liners did. I have those little gel pots in all sorts of colors!

 

[Deeeee306]

Bobbi Brown's gel eyeliner! It's doesn't flake, ash, or rub off unless using eye makeup remover. The little pot lasts a long time. HTH.

 

[me_love_purse]

i like stila smudgepot

 

[rensky]

dior waterproof eyeliners, my all time fav!

 

[madamefifi]

Chanel is my fave but I recently bought a Nars eyeliner pencil that I like as well. I always use Benefit F...Y...Eye to prime my eyelids before applying liner or shadow. Works great! So does Urban Decay primer.

 

[FullyLoaded]

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On pencil in Zero (black). My friend that works in Sephora said a bunch of women brought it back to the store in a panic because they though it could NOT come off. (You need to use an oil-based remover to get it off)

It's jet-black and goes on very smoothly.

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil at Sephora

 

[DeeDeeDelovely]

for maximum staying power: Bobby Brown's gel liner.

 

[LoVe23]

I really like le crayon kohl by Chanel! They give your eyes unbelievable depth and you don't have to use a lot to get the desired result!

that's what i use and i love it!

 

[LadyFran]

I use a quad pack of cake eyeliner from Chanel. I just wet my eyeliner brush, sweep on a little and it lasts forever! I then use the DuWop reversible eyeliner pen underneath my bottom liner to ensure it wont sweat off in the Texas heat.

 

[DenimShopaholic]

I didn't buy it in black, but I just got a liner by Hard Candy that I am loving...and believe me, I am totally eyeliner challenged. It's got the liner on one end (the kind you scroll up, not a pencil), and a smudge brush on the other, with a shadow in the middle section for softening/smudging, etc. I really like it so far, it's very versatile, and they had it in several colors at Sephora, so I am sure you can find it in your color. It's been lasting me all day too, which is a major accomplishment.

Please excuse me for my stupidity...it's not from Hard Candy, it's from Stila. DUH. I swear I am losing my brain cells.......

 

[bal newbie]

I love Chanel's le crayon kohl also...but in graphite. It's silver, different and adds a smokey sparkle and doesn't smudge.