After hearing numerous friends and tPFers rave about Diorshow mascara, I took the plunge...and I hate it. I got the waterproof black Diorshow and it runs more than ANY non waterproof mascara I have ever had. I have never even worn waterproof before because I have never had issues with smudging, rubbing, or dark circles from mascara. I wore it and after 2 hours, it had transferred onto my eyeshadow under my eyebrows, and was under my eyes (I did not even use it on my bottom lashes!) I used to use Lancome Hypnose or Chanel. I think I am going to try Benefit's next and the Diorshow is definitely going back. I am so bummed!