LOL! As I near 5,000 posts I have decided that I'm going to buy my first pair of Coach shoes. It's between Jilly flats in black patent or Josie flats (off eBay) in black signature. I live a pretty casual lifestyle but I am in need of a pair of black flats that can be worn with jeans or nicer slacks. Which should I get? Here's the Jilly flat and Josie (borrowed pic from eBay) Anyone know the item number?