I'm not crazy about it. I say return. It does look like a blanket and nothing special about it.

Maybe if I hadn't seen the first one? This second one can't compare.

I love the first one. But I definitely am not a fan of the second one. It doesn't look nice, rather is looks very hobo (not in a stylish way).

Originally Posted by DC-Cutie

if YOU like it, keep it.

^^^ I'm totally with DC on this
But seeing as your asking TPF members you can't honestly love it?!

I think the first one is much more flattering on you. If it was over 500 dollars and you're unsure, perhaps it might be better to see what else is out there, until you find something you really love?

I love the tan not so much on the gray too..

the black one isn't that great-def return

I like the tan one a lot better. They are to similar to keep both for the price. BUT if you like it then you should keep it.

Not crazy about the dark gray...something about it looks kinda gloomy to me... sorry!

The first one looks great, I'm not a fan of the second one (black/grey) though.

I love the first one, but don't like the second. I'd return and get something you love.

ok honestly, I don't like it. I am sure you can find something that'll sing to you more than this...even if it is sold out. If you are asking then I'd let it go. GL!

I've always loved burberry... I say keep if it, BUT only if you know you will wear it at least 3 times this winter. Right now in my life, I'd probably neglect it (it's where I live)...

Sorry I have been MIA from this thread for a few days, I got really busy between work and kids....and then throw in a sick hubby, and there is no time left in the day, or night for that matter!

Thank you everyone, SO much for all your input, I really appreciate it!

I am still on the fence about this wrap.... but I think I am leaning towards keeping it simply because it is something that I will wear alot, and I every time I think about driving up to Saks and returning it, I put it on again and then want to think about it some more, lol!
I rarely post "should I keep it" threads, usually I know right away if something works for me....and I can't figure out why this stole is so perplexing!

I did try wearing it with a big chunky belt, and it looks great that way- I like the way it drapes and has more shape.
I also tried different ways of wearing it ( over the shoulder ), that is an option that works as well.
Thanks for those suggestions, juneping and ninja-please!

Exxotic1, LoveMyMarc and jillybean307 suggested trying it with something other than jeans.
I can see wearing it with my black ponte-knit E&J or Theory leggings and black or grey booties to give it a little ooomph!
I will have fun in the next few days trying different outfits.

And yes Swanky, those are my Ice Taupe Eternity boots. I also have them in Black....I adore them, they are so freaking comfortable!

Are your eternity boots true to size? I want to order a pair from Barneys and they have taupe and dirty taupe in stock. Do you know which color is closer to your ice taupe boots. Thanks!