the longest lasting one you have tried! Mine always rub off..

I've tried MAC and Chanel but my favorite is Prestige's waterproof eyeliner. I bought it from CVS and paid about 5 dollars for it, and it doesn't even come off after washing my face unless I really go at it with eye makeup remover.

I've had great luck with -- believe it or not -- Jordana eyeliner. $1.99 at Walgreens. Can't beat that!

mac gel liners stay on forever, they are GREAT!!! you can even use them as shadow or as a base for shadow

MAC's powerpoint eye pencils, fluidline gel, or the liquidlast liner. I have watery eyes, but manage to keep any one of these on all day long.

Try Lancome artist liquid eyeliner.. I has been using it for years, i think it lasts as my skin is oily!

The longer lasting eyeliner ever is MAC's liquidlast liner. I don't recommend them though because they are TOO long lasting and it's nearly impossible to take them off. They can stay on my eyes for days even though I try hard to rub them off with my eye makeup remover.
Also I don't find them easy to apply.
The best are MAC's fluidlines, Bobbi Brown's gel eyeliners and Stila's smudge pots.
They come in a lot of beautiful colours and they last ALL DAY without smudging!!

i heard MAC is good but i really like ALMAY

they stay on the whole day for me =)

Bobbi Brown Gel liners!! I am a convert. They take a little bit of practice to apply, but once you get the hang of it, it's easy. They last forever and do not budge!

Revlon..long lasting eye liner.

I use MAC pencils. I went swimming yesterday and my eyeliner didn't run at all.

stila smuge pots! even my shu uemura oil cleanser has trouble taking all of this off so i have to use a eye makeup remover.

Originally Posted by ChinoisBabe

Bobbi Brown Gel liners!! I am a convert. They take a little bit of practice to apply, but once you get the hang of it, it's easy. They last forever and do not budge!

ITA, you can mix them with vasoline for a smokey look too.

Just the regular Lancome pencil works well for me. I used to think there was no difference between department store brand eyeliners and drugstore brand eyeliners until I tried the Lancome. I wont' go back!

I had same problem as you, after using Bobbi Brown eye gel liner my problem solved!