If it was one of the PLL it would be really shocking. I was thinking maybe aria because she hasnt really had a one on one dream with Alison and not so much a target to A as the other girls but she would have to be working with someone else. But I am leaning towards the twin route at this point unless its someone we have no idea about.

I'm not ruling out a creepy Noel, Mona, Jenna, Garrett, etc. super duper conspiracy.

I kind of hope it's not the twin route....

I'm still thinking Jenna is involved. Maybe the second A was angry at Jenna and tried to kill her off. Maybe she'll help the girls after seeing that they saved her when they could have easily let her die. I don't think any of the parents would get so involved to go after each girl, and I really doubt it's one of the liars. They've all been targeted pretty equally, imo.

I haven't read all the previous posts, but what is the twin theory all about? Who would have a twin?

Holy creepiness! Those dolls.

I don't know about the twin thing, I think it was in the books but I didn't read them all.

I think A is going to be the first A in the books. There are some similarities between things that are happening now and what happened before they were discovered.

Originally Posted by RealDealGirl

Holy creepiness! Those dolls. I don't know about the twin thing, I think it was in the books but I didn't read them all.

Those dolls were SO creepy!

1 week until we find out who A is! Yay!

I knew, when Jenna took off her bandage, that she'd be able to see.

Eww, is Melissa pregnant with Garrett's baby? Gross.

Can't wait until next Monday!

This episode was so creepy!!

So many things happened at the end too! wtf @ Jenna?! and the girls hadn't gone to the police yet, so what is going on with Garrett?

Okay! Soo obviously Jenna has something to do with it, remember at the diner, after the therapist meets with A, the waitress says to whoever A is. What pretty eyes you have or whatever. This last episode when they make it clear that Jenna can see, it's a song about pretty eyes? Coincidence?? Foreshadow? I'm soo stumped on everything else. Spencer's sister has to be guilty with the way her and Garett were talking!

I think Garret got arrested because of page 5. Maybe Toby took it to the police.

Jenna had toby take her to the station to bring page 5 down...that is why i think garrett was arrested, not because of the video with the girls.

that episode was AMAZING. 14 hours later and my mind is still blown! That scene with jenna being able to see, so amazing. also just a great episode over all. i wonder if jenna was being sincere in her apology to the girls...i don't think she was because she was lying about not being able to see and also then she screwed over garrett. but when she said "i'm not the one you should be fearful of" or whatever it was she said...makes me wonder!

i think they're going with the twin thing and that spencer really did see ali's twin.

ETA: I hope it's not Mona. I like her. part of me thinks it was though...maybe she is framing melissa.

I hope it makes sense who A is. I don't want it to be some random character like Lucas or or Mike, I want it to be someone exciting.

Garrett's badge was left at the fire scene too I think, I wonder if the police will find it. I am so excited for next weeks episode! I haven't read the books, but hopefully the story can continue and still be exciting once A is revealed.

i agree, the episode this week was pretty good. that doll hospital was creepier then any other PLL scene for sure! that little damian kid was freaky too.

I'm hoping A makes sense too. although i haven't read the books, i know who A is in the books and about the twins theory but I'm hoping they don't repeat either. if they are going the twins route though, i would assume the 'other' twin was killed and allie is still alive. I'm pretty sure spencer (and emily before) didn't see a hallucination of allie, it had to really be her! though i can't figure out how.

I am stumped. The person in the black gloves seems to have a large frame like a man...

also, A has to be pretty wealthy for paying off all the people in the past (doll shop owner, the psychiatrist buying those TB boots etc).