Midwestern reserve... a southerner in need of advice.
Let me give you a little background:
My family is originally from eastern PA, and my entire extended family still lives there. I lived in NYC during my childhood but when I was 9 we moved to Northwest Arkansas. I was too young for it to be much of a culture shock and I identify myself as southern since I did grow up there.
I now go to college in Michigan and I'm a senior this year. I'm graduating and moving out of Michigan... I hate it here for many reasons but the #1 reason is the people. Maybe it's because I'm used to warm Arkansan attitudes, but people in Michigan are so reserved! Everyone I've mentioned this too says "oh yeah, that's the Midwestern Reserve." Like they know exactly what I'm talking about.
It's this sense that I can never really get to know someone. Like, I have tons of friends but everyone has this shell up. No one really seems to care even, and that bothers me. I remember walking around campus freshman year and being friendly to everyone and having people look at me weird. I even had a friend tell me that "in Michigan, we don't talk to strangers." Ha!
When I call people they don't return my calls. If I call a business and leave a message they don't call me back. This has happened with a jeweler, a well-known bank (multiple times), an EMPLOYER, two doctors... the list goes on. If I call again and get a hold of the person they don't even mention the fact that I left a message asking them to call me back.
This happens with my friends too. I will call them and sometimes they just don't call me back. Then, when they call a few days later they won't even mention that I called them! They do this to each other too so I know it's not a personal thing. There's one girl who NEVER calls anyone back ever and everyone is just like "yeah, she doesn't return calls." Like it's no big deal and that's just how she is. I think it's so rude!
Is it a cultural thing? Because honestly, I have never in my life had to interact with people who don't return calls. It's extremely frustrating when you're trying to schedule appointments or find out test results, need to talk to your broker, get jewelry fixed etc. I was even HIRED at Macy's and the head of the department I was hired to work in called and left me a message to come in, and then when I called her back 5 mins later (I was in class) she didn't pick up so I left her a message. She never returned my call and I ended up leaving her 4 more messages over two weeks. She never returned ANY OF THEM. So I called the HR manager who hired me and she said "Oh yeah, so-and-so has been in I wonder why she isn't returning your calls since you're hired. I'll call you back." And she never did, so I figured F*ck it, I didn't want to work somewhere that operated like that.
I never ever had this problem in Arkansas. When I called people, they called me back. End of story.
It's this general pattern of self-centeredness and coldness that I have seen people in Michigan exhibit over and over again! People in Michigan don't see this at all and consider themselves to be "extremely warm" but I haven't gotten this at all.
Can anyone else relate? Sure I'm moving in 5 months, never to return, but it's been so disheartening to live somewhere for 3 and half years and have no close female relationships to show for it. Maybe it's me, or maybe it's circumstantial. Or maybe I expect too much from relationships. My friends in Arkansas, who I have sadly grown apart from, and I were close like sisters! My friends here, it's like fun to hang out with them but there's no depth. It could be just who my friends are as people, but it's happened too many times with all very different people.
Maybe I'm too friendly and expect too much out of people. I read a book about French women, and the author claims that French women are solitary with a few close life-long friends so I'm trying to remind myself of that. My closest friend lives in Portland OR (she's from Arkansas) and she's amazing, but I never get to see her! We have such a great relationship too.
What's your take on this? I'm very smart, well-dressed, and friendly. I'm not a pariah or anything, just wanted to make that clear.
Last edited by chicbabacool; Dec 13th, 2007 at 05:18 PM.
|