Got the shade Bold Brown. I have only been using it on the upper lash line, so can't comment on the waterline (I use Bobbi Brown pencils for that), but on the upper, at least, it is amazing and didn't budge all day long! I am also impressed with the color payoff. This one's a rich, gorgeous brown with a little bronze shimmer to it... Very subtle shimmer, but great color. It's a smooth, creamy formula and a twist up pencil. No need to press hard or warm it up. It glides on nicely and stays put.