These grew on me. I think they are too waxy in the beginning but once I use some if it gets slightly better. I've tried them all and the summer fruit is my least favorite. I do agree that they are overrated though.
I have gone through one full balm and have two other ones I've been using. Overall, I like them. Don't love them, but don't hate them. I probably would repurchase, as I really like putting the balm on after washing my face in the morning and before applying my lip product for the day. It gives just slight moisture so that it's easy to glide on my lipstick, gloss, or stain as I finish getting ready. But, like most of you said, it's really not that moisturizing.
It's a gift from a friend and i wanted to love it becos of its cute packaging lovely smell and Eco friendly ingredients. Unfortunately my lips keep peeling and I felt like just before having cold sores. I had no choice but to put it away and switch to some medicated ones immediately.
I absolutely do not like this balm. I have the pink one, and 30 secs after I apply it my lips feel totally dry! Also, I have found that even though its cute, I kind of hate the bulky shape. It seems to take up so much room in my bag!