Hello, this is Not authentic.

Originally Posted by Elliespurse

Hello, this is Not authentic.

Thanks

Can i ask what is wrong with it? I can authenticate mulberries in a heartbeat but I have no idea with these...

^I have a long list on this bag but I don't think it's appropriate to talk about it.

Originally Posted by Elliespurse

^I have a long list on this bag but I don't think it's appropriate to talk about it.

Hi, if you can, can you pm me with more info? I can only buy one of these on the preloved market and I don't want to make a hideous mistake... The seller has an original receipt with it. Thanks!

Hi, could anyone help authenticate this handbag? Thank you.

Proenza Schouler Large PS1 shoulder bag
seller: doni_k
id# 27054469878



http://cgi.ebay.com/Proenza-Schouler...#ht_822wt_1167

Hi, this bag is Not authentic in my opinion.

hi - this is my bag and it is indeed authentic, purchased by me from Kirna Zabete. I'd like the previous poster to explain why she claims it is not, and I will respond.

No sorry I will not argue.

It's not a matter of arguing. I have posted on many authentication forums, and I believe it's your obligation to explain the reasons for your opinion - this educates the reader and allows them to form their own judgment.

I have offered evidence for my claim that the bag is real, and you should offer evidence for your claim that it's not. It's irresponsible to offer a damaging opinion like this without an explanation.

I will address any and all authenticity concerns and I have already offered in the listing to provide the winning bidder a copy of the receipt including my personal information, so they can verify my purchase directly with Kirna Zabete.

I believe it's your obligation to explain the reasons for your opinion - this educates the reader and allows them to form their own judgment.

no, Elliespurce have no obligation to explain the reasons - she gives her own opinion that stem from personal experiences

There is not much room for opinion here, as I know for a fact that this is an authentic bag since I purchased it from an authorized retailer. Elliespurse is wrong.

I will also suggest that the reason she refuses to explain her reasons is that she doesn't have any good reasons. The last time she offered her opinion on the authenticity of a PS1, it was based on comparing the bag's photos to photos of a real bag on NET-A-PORTER.

I suggest all readers look themselves - compare my bag with the authentic bag photos on NET-A-PORTER and Kirna Zabete, and then with the fake bag photos on ioffer, and make your own judgments.

I am sure most tpf members are trying to be helpful when they give their opinions on authenticity. I find it very scary that, in this case, the poster is giving an un-informed opinion, and that people might actually listen to her, even though there is no true knowledge behind her statement.

Hi,

I could not find an proenza schouler thread..

Does it look authentic?
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...=STRK:MEWAX:IT

Thanks

Hi, it looks ok to me so far, but the first front pic is not the actual item.

I would like to see a clear front pic of the actual item with the Proenza Schouler text.

I'm also not familiar with which color of the lining was sold with this leather.

Thank you, Elliespurse!