I voted the plum leather, as for me its a little more practical.

But if i were you I'd keep the one I would get the most use out of. It's tricky - they're both so similar yet so different too iykwim. Oooo!

I would definitely keep the leather plum!

I Like the plum colour more.

I prefer the plum also!

I prefer the plum.

I'd keep the plum, just because suede is always harder to care for.

I'm not going to be very helpful but I prefer the grape colour but I prefer the leather

Originally Posted by gem77

Hi, Im having to a dilemma as to sell my mulberry margaret bag in plum or the one in grape. I like 'CoachCruisers' idea of doing a poll to see which would you'd choose. They're both great bags but have to part with one, and i dont want to have any regrets about it afterwards, which i sometimes get after selling rashly. Much appreciated. Thank you. pics : http://s1068.photobucket.com/albums/u460/jhunter6/

Without a doubt i would def keep the plum leather its more practical/hardwearing than the suede and looks nicer.

thank you all for taking the time to respond.

update:
I think im leaning more towards parting with the grape.

I'd keep the plum leather!