I use baby oil & water for my eyes as well! Takes off even waterproof make-up! Works like a charm and cheap! As for my face, i just use a regular clean & clear face wash. I find it to be as effective as anyother brand named cleanser that i've tried.
Location: Athens, Greece and Long Island, New York
To take off my eye make-up which includes liquid eye liner, and mascara I use Bifacil by Lancome love this stuff and for the rest of my make-up I use cetaphil and remove it with a wonder cloth using distilled water.
I usually shower every night before bed, and take off my mascara with just water, then use Cetaphil on my entire face. If any of the mascara stains, I just swipe a little Neutrogena eye make up remover on and dab it off with water. Works perfectly for me.
I switch around a lot. For a while I used Lancome's Bi-Facil. Then, Estee Lauder's Eye Make-up Remover...sometimes their Take It Away make-up remover (I LOVE the smell). I recently tried Beauti Control's Lid and Lash Wash (amazing...better than I expected). If I'm lazy, and I don't feel like doing different cleansing routines, I use Victoria Principal's 4-in-1 Gentle Deep Cleanser, which I have been using since high school. I love it, but I'm a product hound who can't stay faithful to one product!
I always take my make-up off when I'm going to bed (but I've got to admire you ladies who take it off as soon as you get in from work - can only be good!)
At the minute I'm using Shu Uemura oil to remove my makeup (the green one) and using Gatineau Floricil to remove eye makeup. I'm very happy with both and then I use Dr.Hauschka Facial Toner to finish off with.
I take off my makeup before I go to bed. On the nights I'm at the gym, I take it off as soon as I get home (I go to the gym straight from work and live close to my gym so I just shower/change when I get home).
My favorite eye makeup removers:
Lancome Bi Facils
When I travel for business I try to limit the amount of liquids for the carry on/ziplock 3oz rule, which means I try to get away with no eye makeup remover. I use liquid liner and a stronger cleanser as an alternative, to avoid the need to pack eye makeup remover...