Home > >

What do you do when your fave color is discontinued?

Thread Tools
Jun 18, 2012, 11:07pm   #1
tomatored's Avatar
Thread Starter
I, my favorite YSL lip color Praline Delight is discontinued and I've only been able to find poor quality drugstore close matches. What do you all do when this happens? Suggestions?
Jun 19, 2012, 1:01am   #2
musthaveseenher's Avatar
we're all mad here.
Scour eBay and lesser known beauty sites that may still have stock of what you want and buy up where you can.
Jun 19, 2012, 7:26am   #3
19flowers's Avatar
I can usually find disc. lipsticks on ebay -- good luck!
Jun 19, 2012, 5:00pm   #4
Cait's Avatar
only once you live
Custom Color Specialists. I don't recall the exact name, but they have pigment formulas on file (or you can send the old tube in) and they could remix it for you.
Jun 19, 2012, 5:17pm   #5
DC-Cutie's Avatar
3 custom color
Jun 20, 2012, 5:08pm   #6
-Look to see if a dupe is listed on temptalia http://www.temptalia.com/makeup-dupe-list
-google Product name and add "dupe" http://www.google.com/search?q=%22pr...&client=safari
-google product name and add "swatch"

ysl sensuous silk comes close

Essentially your looking for a nude....these are some potentials
Jun 20, 2012, 11:48pm   #7
tomatored's Avatar
Thread Starter
Wow! Thanks everyone! I am so pleased by your responses. I'll get going right away with your suggestions and let you know. You are all great!
Jun 21, 2012, 12:40am   #8
I cry.

No I'm kidding. I scour ebay and buy up all the ones that I can. If you really love it/can't live without it, try the 3 custom colors website above. They will replicate ANYTHING. Even create lipsticks and eyeshadows off photos of colors.
Jun 21, 2012, 10:09pm   #9
Pursegrrl's Avatar
Oh no she di-int!!
After I have a brief mourning period ;-)
...I go on the brand website and try to snap up as many of what's being discontinued as I can. I remember doing this a few years ago with a Lancome foundation and I (no joke) stored what I was able to get in the fridge until I needed it.

Will have to check out the 3 custom colors site...looks pretty cool!

Jun 21, 2012, 11:41pm   #10
tomatored's Avatar
Thread Starter
Well I've been to all the suggested places and no dupes were recorded yet for my color. So I'm going to eBay tonight to get one there and then send it to the Three place. I actually lost my last tube on vacation, so I don't even have an original to send them so I'll get one on eBay. Now I have found two excellent matches in drugstore brands but, I don't like the textures of either, and I hate the ugly tubes! I know it sounds crazy, but one of them is so heavily fragranced that I take the cap off and let it air out before I apply. The colors are perfect though: NYX Rea, and Maybelline Beige For Good. I love that you hoard your fave cosmetics! That's so funny and smart! As I tell my husband, being a woman is so complicated, he can never hope to understand, don't even try!
Jul 3, 2012, 12:04pm   #11
usually try to find a dupe...
this site is pretty good
Jul 3, 2012, 9:58pm   #12
tomatored's Avatar
Thread Starter
Thanks every one! I am happy to report I have found a perfect duplicate, like 99.9 % perfect. It's MAC's Fresh Brew. I'm going to try to post a picture.
What I had to do was, I followed all of your advice and found a full sized new, un-opened tube of my YSL 24 on Ebay, with the intention of sending a swatch to Three Custom Colors. But I had to travel to Chicago Monday so I took it to the MAC Counter at Nordstrom and the Pro there took a lot of time to find a match for it. She was very sharp, and very determined! We were both amazed at the near perfection of the match.
You are all so helpful,

Name:  image-859113389.jpg
Views: 428
Size:  505.5 KB

Name:  image-2450107999.jpg
Views: 374
Size:  561.2 KB

I am really grateful. And I'm going to try Three Custom Colors and see how close they get in case this ever happens again. I mean I've lost beloved shades before, but losing 24 after all this time was quite a blow. Anyway with all your help I'm out of mourning! I had no idea there were those great sites like TCC and Temptalia.
Jul 4, 2012, 11:27am   #13
exotikittenx's Avatar
Ooh la la!
Great match! MAC lipsticks are fabulous and have sleek, chic packaging. Not as pretty as YSL, but nice on their own.
Jul 4, 2012, 11:41am   #14
tomatored's Avatar
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by exotikittenx
Great match! MAC lipsticks are fabulous and have sleek, chic packaging. Not as pretty as YSL, but nice on their own.
The formula is a little more moisturizing, but I can live with that, I just blot it with a little powder. And yes, i'm actually really liking the black bullet packaging, it's a new and different dynamic for me but it's very cool. Couldn't be more pleased!
Jul 4, 2012, 8:36pm   #15
Llisa's Avatar
Glad to hear that your have found a best one. It's a fine thing to find a best product! Isn't it?
  HOME > >  

Thread Tools