Ladies! Thank you for the lovely responses - it was such an unexpected surprise to login and see all these suggestions. I'm checking them out one-by-one and have already found some nice bags.
My "tight" budget is between $50 - $80 (depending on how badly I end up wanting it heh) and thanks to your suggestions, I now have some real possibilities!
Quick question though - Tignanello.. would you recommend it in general, or only the pebbled leather version (nobody seems to have mentioned their glove leather bags)?
I've seen some cute B Makowsky bags but there were negative reviews on the quality of his lining & hardware so I think I should steer clear of them.