I actually think this price is more than fair. For me personally, the tags are not particularly important. Also, you may be able to get tassels at BNY and then a dustbag is a dustbag. Rose is very rare color to come by. Moreover, this bag is in mint condition and is '04 leather, which is incredible. Additionally, you are paying for a bag that not many people have because the older bags were made in much more limited quantities and perhaps one could argue that the quality is therefore better. Once you have one, you see that not only is the leather amazing but the colors are so rich. I don't mean to start a debate on old vs. new but when you see people who have owned old bags continuing to seek these bags and pay more than retail for them, there must be something there.