AARGH!! Mid-Aft, Guccissima or Gaucho?

[LaineeGirl]

I need a classy NOT trendy, sassy and NOT boring dark red bag!

So I'm asking you lovely diehard bbag gals for your votes on each of these bags plus your *honest* opinions! THANKS!!!

1. Bordeaux/Grenat Balenciaga Mid-Afternoon - Diabro $926
2. Bordeaux Guccissima Bouvier - Bluefly $771
3. Wine Dior Gaucho - Diabro $841

 

[Cheshire Cat]

Grenat is the most versitile red bag I have ever owned. And although I think the other two are cute, I also think that they fall firmly into the "trendy" category. The Mid-Afternoon is for sure the most sophisticated and timeless looking of the three.

 

[LaineeGirl]

Thanks! Here are PICS:

 

[girlycharlie]

To be completely honest, I have the Guccissima Bouvier and I love it I've also bought and returned a Mid-Afternoon. The Bouvier is classier, IMHO... Errr, no stone throwing, please

 

[Cheshire Cat]

Seeing them side by side that way, I might change my vote to the Bouvier as well...

 

[LaineeGirl]

To be completely honest, I have the Guccissima Bouvier and I love it I've also bought and returned a Mid-Afternoon. The Bouvier is classier, IMHO... Errr, no stone throwing, please

Thanks for the honesty! The gucci's arriving today but I was drawn to the bbag and dior on Diabro, which doesn't accept returns. Can't wait to see what others say...

 

[LaineeGirl]

Seeing them side by side that way, I might change my vote to the Bouvier as well...

Thanks Cheshire Cat!!

 

[kathleen]

I went for the bbag even though the mid-aft is not my favorite style but that gucci is quite a looker!!!! I might be willing to jump the bal ship for that baby. I love the dior but I think it will look really silly in a few years.

 

[guccidiva]

I need a classy NOT trendy, sassy and NOT boring dark red bag!

So I'm asking you lovely diehard bbag gals for your votes on each of these bags plus your *honest* opinions! THANKS!!!

1. Bordeaux/Grenat Balenciaga Mid-Afternoon - Diabro $926
2. Bordeaux Guccissima Bouvier - Bluefly $771
3. Wine Dior Gaucho - Diabro $841

Actually, have you looked into Jimmy Choo Ramona or Riki in burgundy (it's a dark red)? Very classy, not trendy and def. not boring

 

[fiatflux]

I vote for the Gucci. I personally don't care for the Mid-Afternoon style. The Dior is way too trendy, although I love it.

 

[thithi]

I like the Dior, but voted for the Mid-Afternoon. I love grenat! I think the Dior Gauchos will be outdated soon.

 

[Celia_Hish]

My choice will be to bbag grenat mid-afternoon which i think is the most versatile style and color.....it's my fav color as well as it looks very similar to my beloved bordeaux.....

 

[lizz]

I've always liked the Gaucho bag, but who's to say it won't look trendy in a few years? So I voted for the Dior.