Help...I am being so "fickle"....

LVDevotee · Apr 3rd, 2008, 12:02 AM

Thanks to all who clarified the resin modern chain in my previous post. Today I bought a white resin modern chain tote (can't pick it up til next week to get Saks triple points!).

But...I am driving myself crazy deciding if I really want this or if I want the GST.

I am looking for a fun casual summer bag. The GST is gorgeous and classic, it is the caviar which is more durable and it will be in style forever. But...It is more structured than I am looking for and I would like a zip on the top. I love the white MC tote as it is a more relaxed style, I like how soft the calf skin is, and I like that it zips at the top. But, I am concerned about durability (with the white calfskin and the resin chains) and that I will get tired of this one sooner as it is not a classic like the GST.

Hmmmm..GST: classic, functional, and more durable or Resin Modern ChainTote: fun, relaxed, soft, zip top?? Bottomline, I do prefer the resin chain tote, but do I want to spend almost $3,000 for a bag that might not stand the test of time?? What do all of you chanel aficionados think? Thanks!

trishaluvslv · Apr 3rd, 2008, 01:04 AM

this is the age old dilemma....i have to say, I have the n/s modern chain with the metal hardware from 07', as much as I LOVEe it, i would sell it if something better came along, But I just got my third GST (blakc, white and now beige w/ shw) and every time i pull one out of storage to wear, I fall in love all over again. i have never and will never sell my GST's, even if I needed food or dental work and was flat broke

they work casual, dressy, over the shoulder, on the arm, in the hand, you name it.....diaper bag, with a suit......I always feel like a million bucks with my GST or my jumbo flap! good luck deciding! tough call! Gotta add, for the GSTprice, you get alot of bag for $2125!!!!

DD101 · Apr 3rd, 2008, 01:14 AM

The GST is definetly a classic (and gorgeous too), but it sounds like you like the softer MC. As much as I like the look of the GST, it's way too boxy for me and I know it would never work. Witht the exceptions of the flaps, I like soft smooshy bags, but that's just me. Don't just get a bag because it's classic and you think you'll have it forever. Know what works for you. Try the GST on, put all your stuff in it and see if it's comfortable.

Good luck choosing, both bags are stunning!

Aurora · Apr 3rd, 2008, 01:22 AM

I would go for the GST if you're looking for classic, function and durability. It's something you will use in years to come but I can't say the same about the modern chain tote with resin handles. With what you're paying for, I would prefer metal over plastic. However the MC tote does have an edgy look. I agree with DD101, go try on the GST and see how you like it!

janny328 · Apr 3rd, 2008, 02:40 AM

Personally, I'd go for the GST -for many of the reasons the lovely gals before me have stated... and I think the GST is a bit more "classic" than any of the resin bags.

I-shop · Apr 3rd, 2008, 02:47 AM

If you're looking for modern and trendy and young go for the MC tote. If classy is your choice then go for GST! I also love the GST and on my buy list but still thinking about the color, and waiting for seasonal color. You'll never go wrong with GST.

But go whichever you heart tells you!

ladydeluxe · Apr 3rd, 2008, 03:40 AM

IMO, I wouldn't go for the MC resin chain bag at all (especially after owning the original MC tote bag). Firstly, the resin chain just gets to me - the whole plastic pvc thing. I don't care what they say about the 'high tech plastic' they use for the chains because to me, plastic means plastic.

Secondly, the recalling of the previous batch of resin chain MC bags still bugs me! I can't believe they relisted another batch for this season!!! And like what you said, I don't think this bag can survive the test of time because plastic seems to be a 'trend'.

Anyhooo, that's just my personal opinion! I think the GST is still hands down a timeless classic tote bag. It's a bag in that good ol' fashion manner and it's just one of those essential tote bags you'll need in your wardrobe that goes well with anything and everything (just like a black jumbo flap), kwim?

I hope you make the right choice and go with something that makes you happy. That's the most important! Good luck with deciding!

missisa07 · Apr 3rd, 2008, 03:49 AM

Definitely the GST for me. I have one and love it. I love the old modern chain ligne with the metal chain, but the new resin chain is much too trendy and I'd be a lot more worried about it breaking.

roey · Apr 3rd, 2008, 03:51 AM

I find my black GST to be a great "go to" tote when I need something I don't mind setting down in places like hair and nail salons or meetings at the gym for fear it will get ruined. My GST was purchased in 2006 and still looks brand new. I wouldn't take my MC tote to these places. Even though the leather is distressed and hardy, it is also more porous. I don't think a liquid spill would wipe right off the MC leather like it would with caviar.

LVDevotee · Apr 3rd, 2008, 08:06 AM

Thank you so much for the thoughts. I am new to Chanel and really value your opinions!

I will let you know what I decide and of course post pics.

Fauve · Apr 3rd, 2008, 09:12 AM

I would go classic and the GST is a great and very versatile bag.

I was not loving the plastic chain on the MC tote, though I loved the rest of the bag. How does the chain feel? On me it felt flimsy and too fussy.

psulion08 · Apr 3rd, 2008, 09:18 AM

I love the GST!

japskivt · Apr 3rd, 2008, 10:12 AM

I am not a GST fan, but I think it is much more durable and practical than the resin MC.

margaritas · Apr 3rd, 2008, 10:31 AM

You didn't mention what colour you want for the GST, so how about a white GST if you could get one? :)

LVDevotee · Apr 3rd, 2008, 11:03 AM

Yes, They had a white one with silver H/w. I keep thinking that the MC tote goes better with casual summer dresses (which I live in). I know that the GST is much more likely to "stand the test of time" but do you guys think that it is kind of structured/bulky to go w casual summer dresses??

Apr 3rd, 2008, 12:02 AM	#1
LVDevotee Member	Help...I am being so "fickle".... Thanks to all who clarified the resin modern chain in my previous post. Today I bought a white resin modern chain tote (can't pick it up til next week to get Saks triple points!). But...I am driving myself crazy deciding if I really want this or if I want the GST. I am looking for a fun casual summer bag. The GST is gorgeous and classic, it is the caviar which is more durable and it will be in style forever. But...It is more structured than I am looking for and I would like a zip on the top. I love the white MC tote as it is a more relaxed style, I like how soft the calf skin is, and I like that it zips at the top. But, I am concerned about durability (with the white calfskin and the resin chains) and that I will get tired of this one sooner as it is not a classic like the GST. Hmmmm..GST: classic, functional, and more durable or Resin Modern ChainTote: fun, relaxed, soft, zip top?? Bottomline, I do prefer the resin chain tote, but do I want to spend almost $3,000 for a bag that might not stand the test of time?? What do all of you chanel aficionados think? Thanks!

Apr 3rd, 2008, 01:04 AM	#2
trishaluvslv Member Location: Valley of the Sun	Re: Help...I am being so "fickle".... this is the age old dilemma....i have to say, I have the n/s modern chain with the metal hardware from 07', as much as I LOVEe it, i would sell it if something better came along, But I just got my third GST (blakc, white and now beige w/ shw) and every time i pull one out of storage to wear, I fall in love all over again. i have never and will never sell my GST's, even if I needed food or dental work and was flat broke they work casual, dressy, over the shoulder, on the arm, in the hand, you name it.....diaper bag, with a suit......I always feel like a million bucks with my GST or my jumbo flap! good luck deciding! tough call! Gotta add, for the GSTprice, you get alot of bag for $2125!!!! __________________ "you can tell the heart of a man in his dealings with animals" - Immanual Kant, Philosopher H wishlist 1. Poussiere, Biscuit, Camel-tabac or sable 35cm birkin phw, togo or fjord 2. Vert chartreuse 35 cm birkin togo or chevre w phw 3. 32 HAC in Chevre ANY COLOR ( GOT It 6/08 - 32 HAC in Rouge VIF chevre ) Last edited by trishaluvslv; Apr 3rd, 2008 at 01:05 AM. Reason: spelling

Apr 3rd, 2008, 01:14 AM	#3
DD101 A League Of My Own Location: NJ	Re: Help...I am being so "fickle".... The GST is definetly a classic (and gorgeous too), but it sounds like you like the softer MC. As much as I like the look of the GST, it's way too boxy for me and I know it would never work. Witht the exceptions of the flaps, I like soft smooshy bags, but that's just me. Don't just get a bag because it's classic and you think you'll have it forever. Know what works for you. Try the GST on, put all your stuff in it and see if it's comfortable. Good luck choosing, both bags are stunning! __________________

Apr 3rd, 2008, 01:22 AM	#4
Aurora Member	Re: Help...I am being so "fickle".... I would go for the GST if you're looking for classic, function and durability. It's something you will use in years to come but I can't say the same about the modern chain tote with resin handles. With what you're paying for, I would prefer metal over plastic. However the MC tote does have an edgy look. I agree with DD101, go try on the GST and see how you like it!

Apr 3rd, 2008, 02:40 AM	#5
janny328 <3's chanel Location: Los Angeles	Re: Help...I am being so "fickle".... Personally, I'd go for the GST -for many of the reasons the lovely gals before me have stated... and I think the GST is a bit more "classic" than any of the resin bags.

Apr 3rd, 2008, 02:47 AM	#6
I-shop call me Irene Location: Coconut Land	Re: Help...I am being so "fickle".... If you're looking for modern and trendy and young go for the MC tote. If classy is your choice then go for GST! I also love the GST and on my buy list but still thinking about the color, and waiting for seasonal color. You'll never go wrong with GST. But go whichever you heart tells you! __________________ I'm looking for my UHG, a PINK/RASPBERRY MINIBOUT in 37.5 or 38. PLEASE PLEASE HELP ME FIND THIS!! I don't have shopping list. I want EVERYTHING!!!

Apr 3rd, 2008, 03:40 AM	#7
ladydeluxe I shop therefore I'm	Re: Help...I am being so "fickle".... IMO, I wouldn't go for the MC resin chain bag at all (especially after owning the original MC tote bag). Firstly, the resin chain just gets to me - the whole plastic pvc thing. I don't care what they say about the 'high tech plastic' they use for the chains because to me, plastic means plastic. Secondly, the recalling of the previous batch of resin chain MC bags still bugs me! I can't believe they relisted another batch for this season!!! And like what you said, I don't think this bag can survive the test of time because plastic seems to be a 'trend'. Anyhooo, that's just my personal opinion! I think the GST is still hands down a timeless classic tote bag. It's a bag in that good ol' fashion manner and it's just one of those essential tote bags you'll need in your wardrobe that goes well with anything and everything (just like a black jumbo flap), kwim? I hope you make the right choice and go with something that makes you happy. That's the most important! Good luck with deciding! __________________ “I have the simplest taste. I'm always satisfied with the best.” - Oscar Wilde Ladydeluxe's Couture Closet http://mycouturecloset.blogspot.com Designer shoes, bags and clothings! Last edited by ladydeluxe; Apr 3rd, 2008 at 03:44 AM.

Apr 3rd, 2008, 03:49 AM	#8
missisa07 (Isabel) Location: Hawaii	Re: Help...I am being so "fickle".... Definitely the GST for me. I have one and love it. I love the old modern chain ligne with the metal chain, but the new resin chain is much too trendy and I'd be a lot more worried about it breaking. __________________ ^link to my blog! LOVE YOUR LIFE.

Apr 3rd, 2008, 03:51 AM	#9
roey Member Location: In the sunshine!	Re: Help...I am being so "fickle".... I find my black GST to be a great "go to" tote when I need something I don't mind setting down in places like hair and nail salons or meetings at the gym for fear it will get ruined. My GST was purchased in 2006 and still looks brand new. I wouldn't take my MC tote to these places. Even though the leather is distressed and hardy, it is also more porous. I don't think a liquid spill would wipe right off the MC leather like it would with caviar.

Apr 3rd, 2008, 08:06 AM	#10
LVDevotee Member	Re: Help...I am being so "fickle".... Thank you so much for the thoughts. I am new to Chanel and really value your opinions! I will let you know what I decide and of course post pics.

Apr 3rd, 2008, 09:12 AM	#11
Fauve Member Location: NYC	Re: Help...I am being so "fickle".... I would go classic and the GST is a great and very versatile bag. I was not loving the plastic chain on the MC tote, though I loved the rest of the bag. How does the chain feel? On me it felt flimsy and too fussy.

Apr 3rd, 2008, 09:18 AM	#12
psulion08 I want it all	Re: Help...I am being so "fickle".... I love the GST! __________________ Wishlist: LV Kate Clutch Christian Louboutin shoes

Apr 3rd, 2008, 10:12 AM	#13
japskivt Member Location: NY	Re: Help...I am being so "fickle".... I am not a GST fan, but I think it is much more durable and practical than the resin MC.

Apr 3rd, 2008, 10:31 AM	#14
margaritas Member Location: Singapore	Re: Help...I am being so "fickle".... You didn't mention what colour you want for the GST, so how about a white GST if you could get one? :)

Apr 3rd, 2008, 11:03 AM	#15
LVDevotee Member	Re: Help...I am being so "fickle".... Yes, They had a white one with silver H/w. I keep thinking that the MC tote goes better with casual summer dresses (which I live in). I know that the GST is much more likely to "stand the test of time" but do you guys think that it is kind of structured/bulky to go w casual summer dresses??