Botkier Sasha or Gustto Setela? Which one?

iluvmybags · May 5th, 2007, 03:27 AM

Trying to decide between these two bags.

Gustto Large Setela - Tobacco
http://www.activeendeavors.com/produ...&pfid=AED18792

Botkier Sasha - Pudding
http://www.activeendeavors.com/produ...&pfid=AED18458

Given the choice, which would you choose & why? Owners of either, please give me your feedback on the quality of the leather, the workmanship, weight & how well the bag holds up.

Crystalina · May 5th, 2007, 03:32 AM

The first one looks HUGE! The second one is large too, but it seems to be a little smaller maybe. I'd go for the second one.

Lexie2000 · May 5th, 2007, 03:37 AM

I like the Setela in this case even though I love Botkiers. The more I see the Sasha the more I dislike the buckled straps on the front. The Setela is such a charming bag. One day I may have to find one.

iluvmybags · May 5th, 2007, 03:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lexie2000

The more I see the Sasha the more I dislike the buckled straps on the front.

Have you seen the pics of Angelina Jolie w/her Sasha Duffle? It looks like she took the handles off so that you don't have the straps & big buckles - It actually looks kinda cool (although I wouldn't do that cuz I'd probably use the handles more than the strap).

iluvmybags · May 5th, 2007, 03:47 AM

One thing I wonder about the Setela - for those of you who own one or have seen it in person - does it look much like a Bowling Bag? I haven't seen this bag in person yet, but in some pics, it's shape reminds me of a Bowling Ball Bag. Maybe it depends on how you stuff it, but I just wondered.

tenmosquito · May 5th, 2007, 03:48 AM

they are both so pretty!
then again I am a fan of both brands hahaa

I wanted to buy the Black Sasha tote - but when I placed the order in at Active Endeavors it emailed me back in an hours or so saying it was sold out! THE 2ND TIME! I am rather discouraged from buying from them simply because everytime I placed an order for something they were sold out of it after I placed the order... its frustrating on my part...

Are you concerned about weight? I have picked up both and the Setela is much lighter by comparison...

I would want both! So I can't help you decide hahaa!

tenmosquito · May 5th, 2007, 03:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iluvmybags

One thing I wonder about the Setela - for those of you who own one or have seen it in person - does it look much like a Bowling Bag? I haven't seen this bag in person yet, but in some pics, it's shape reminds me of a Bowling Ball Bag. Maybe it depends on how you stuff it, but I just wondered.

Well the thing is - the bag is really light and slouchy.. so when you put it down it will definitely not retain its shape - but when you put it on you can see the shape but it is really not that stiff...

Am I making any sense? haha

iluvmybags · May 5th, 2007, 03:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tenmosquito

Well the thing is - the bag is really light and slouchy.. so when you put it down it will definitely not retain its shape - but when you put it on you can see the shape but it is really not that stiff...

Am I making any sense? haha

I get what you're saying! Weight isn't too much of an issue, although I would prefer a lighter bag. I've actually been leaning towards the Sasha mainly because of the dual handles/shoulder strap. Although I like to carry my bags on my arms, there are times I need to put it on my shoulder, and I don't think the Setela would fit nicely on my shoulder (esp if I had on a heavier jacket). I also don't like it when a bag sits directly under my armpit (I have to walk to work & in the summer when it's hot, that could lead to an unpleasant occurrence!!!) But I have had my eye on the Setela ever since I first started seeing them.

iluvmybags · May 5th, 2007, 04:23 AM

for those of you who have suggested the Setela - how well does the lining hold up? For such nice bags, I always thought Gustto linings looked kinda "cheapie." They could at least do them in black or ivory - did they have to choose canary yellow???

tenmosquito · May 5th, 2007, 04:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by iluvmybags

for those of you who have suggested the Setela - how well does the lining hold up? For such nice bags, I always thought Gustto linings looked kinda "cheapie." They could at least do them in black or ivory - did they have to choose canary yellow???

I totally agree! I am not a fan of that yellow!
I also love the Setela since it came out! I am desperately waiting for one to go on sale so I can get one!

bebe34 · May 5th, 2007, 07:55 AM

I would go for the Botkier.

I LOVE the shape and the look of the Gustto, but don't think that the quality is up to par for the price. I ordered a large Setela from SummerBlu when they were having their extra 40% off. I really liked the bag -- and for less than $400 I loved the price! -- but after one day of wearing the strap was coming apart. They allowed me to return it for an exchange, but I'm still waiting for the replacement bag nearly two weeks later. Sigh.

Considering the bags are about the same price point I think that Botkier quality is far superior. If you're ordering from Active use "apologies" for 25% off.

mrs depoint · May 5th, 2007, 08:52 AM

I was lusting over the Botker Sasha duffle yesterday and finally saw it at Nordstrom. The strap leather (across the front) and the leather of the body of the bag are two different types: one's hard, the latter is squishy, with a kind of sheen. Made we wonder how well the thing would age. Anyway, I passed on it. See if you can see these in person to decide.

songofthesea · May 6th, 2007, 12:04 AM

i just got a gustto and the leather is amazing! i've also owned botkiers and i don't think the leather wears as well although they are GORGEOUS!!!!

SilverSea · May 6th, 2007, 12:26 AM

I love the botkier sasha!!

ThisIsMyPurse · May 6th, 2007, 01:35 AM

Mrs. Depoint==can you explain more about what you mean -- which parts have different leather?

Iluvmybags--I think I see handles on Angelina's bag....

silversea--have you had a Gustto before your new one? Just wondering why you think the Gustto leather will wear better.

May 5th, 2007, 03:32 AM	#2
Crystalina Member Location: West Coast	Re: Botkier Sasha or Gustto Setela? Which one? The first one looks HUGE! The second one is large too, but it seems to be a little smaller maybe. I'd go for the second one.

May 5th, 2007, 03:37 AM	#3
Lexie2000 Pursonally Affected Location: Wild Wonderful West Virginia	Re: Botkier Sasha or Gustto Setela? Which one? I like the Setela in this case even though I love Botkiers. The more I see the Sasha the more I dislike the buckled straps on the front. The Setela is such a charming bag. One day I may have to find one. __________________

May 5th, 2007, 03:47 AM	#5
iluvmybags Ice, Ice Baby! Location: Chicago (and PROUD of it!)	Re: Botkier Sasha or Gustto Setela? Which one? One thing I wonder about the Setela - for those of you who own one or have seen it in person - does it look much like a Bowling Bag? I haven't seen this bag in person yet, but in some pics, it's shape reminds me of a Bowling Ball Bag. Maybe it depends on how you stuff it, but I just wondered.

May 5th, 2007, 03:48 AM	#6
tenmosquito complete bagaholic... Location: Toronto -> Upstate NY -> Pearl of the Orient	Re: Botkier Sasha or Gustto Setela? Which one? they are both so pretty! then again I am a fan of both brands hahaa I wanted to buy the Black Sasha tote - but when I placed the order in at Active Endeavors it emailed me back in an hours or so saying it was sold out! THE 2ND TIME! I am rather discouraged from buying from them simply because everytime I placed an order for something they were sold out of it after I placed the order... its frustrating on my part... Are you concerned about weight? I have picked up both and the Setela is much lighter by comparison... I would want both! So I can't help you decide hahaa! __________________ YAY! Can proudly say that I have a complete Lesportsac Tokidoki collection!

May 5th, 2007, 04:23 AM	#9
iluvmybags Ice, Ice Baby! Location: Chicago (and PROUD of it!)	Re: Botkier Sasha or Gustto Setela? Which one? for those of you who have suggested the Setela - how well does the lining hold up? For such nice bags, I always thought Gustto linings looked kinda "cheapie." They could at least do them in black or ivory - did they have to choose canary yellow???

May 5th, 2007, 07:55 AM	#11
bebe34 Member	Re: Botkier Sasha or Gustto Setela? Which one? I would go for the Botkier. I LOVE the shape and the look of the Gustto, but don't think that the quality is up to par for the price. I ordered a large Setela from SummerBlu when they were having their extra 40% off. I really liked the bag -- and for less than $400 I loved the price! -- but after one day of wearing the strap was coming apart. They allowed me to return it for an exchange, but I'm still waiting for the replacement bag nearly two weeks later. Sigh. Considering the bags are about the same price point I think that Botkier quality is far superior. If you're ordering from Active use "apologies" for 25% off.

May 5th, 2007, 08:52 AM	#12
mrs depoint Member	Re: Botkier Sasha or Gustto Setela? Which one? I was lusting over the Botker Sasha duffle yesterday and finally saw it at Nordstrom. The strap leather (across the front) and the leather of the body of the bag are two different types: one's hard, the latter is squishy, with a kind of sheen. Made we wonder how well the thing would age. Anyway, I passed on it. See if you can see these in person to decide.

May 6th, 2007, 12:04 AM	#13
songofthesea lovemybags! Location: red sox, patriot and celtics territory!!!	Re: Botkier Sasha or Gustto Setela? Which one? i just got a gustto and the leather is amazing! i've also owned botkiers and i don't think the leather wears as well although they are GORGEOUS!!!!

May 6th, 2007, 12:26 AM	#14
SilverSea Member	Re: Botkier Sasha or Gustto Setela? Which one? I love the botkier sasha!! __________________ My Coach wish list: Brass/Berry Sabrina Brass/Berry Madison mini skinny Penguin Keyfob

May 6th, 2007, 01:35 AM	#15
ThisIsMyPurse Member	Re: Botkier Sasha or Gustto Setela? Which one? Mrs. Depoint==can you explain more about what you mean -- which parts have different leather? Iluvmybags--I think I see handles on Angelina's bag.... silversea--have you had a Gustto before your new one? Just wondering why you think the Gustto leather will wear better. __________________